What would Oz or Josh thought about modern resos?

594 reads
Dean Upson's picture

This is the sort of a question that may not have an answer because they have both passed away.  I often wonder what Josh Graves or Oswald Kirby would think of the open bodied, large bodied resos that are so popular now as compared to the soundwell design that was used "in the day".

Dean

None

Comments

bluegrass2's picture

It is a good question Dean! I couldn't even begin to offer a speculation about that...Hard to know what went on in those super picker stylist brains?...All I know is that they could sure suck the marrow out whatever dobro bone they chewed on..

Dan'l.

Dean Upson's picture

I agree! I would have loved to have heard them play "End of the World" or "Just Joshin'" played on a Clinesmith, Meredith or a HornCool.

Dean

Joey's picture

That is indeed a great question. I don't use a Ouija Board, so I don't know, but it brought to mind a related question:

If they had these modern tools available, and embraced them, how would their music have changed, if at all?

 

I know different instruments inspire me and pull me in different ways musically, to make best use of their sonic qualities.

__________________

www.JoeyAce.com

Dean Upson's picture

I'll go out on a limb and say that I think that their music would have been much the same with a different sound.

Dean

Preston Thompson's picture

   To add just a bit of thought to this, I once had a conversation with Gregg McKenna in regards to the soundwell and if he built the open body, post style guitars. Well I just about got blessed out for even mentioning the post style. He built the soundwell style and that it. So along that line of thinking, if Gregg was that steadfast in his way of thinking, I can't help but think the the pickers of yesteryear would have about the same mind set. But then I still think Jerry's RQ Jones sounded better than the present Beard.

 

  pt

__________________

aka PLTreso

tabtabscott's picture

I had several long talks with Josh about stuff like that when we were recording together at Ironwood in Seattle...I had brought along the Scheerhorn I was playing at the time, and while he liked it, or said he did, he didn't want to use it on tape when I offered. He said something to the effect "Its got too much horsepower for me"...He was using the guitar with the seahorses on the top at the time. He did tell me that the one he loved the most was Julie...one that had been stolen and then returned...

Man oh man, I wish I had had the forsesight to record those conversations...he told story after story about travelling on the bus with Flatt & Scruggs, Kenny Baker, etc...it was priceless, and probably the most fabulous afternoons of my life, getting to hang with "The Man"...

My good friend Dale Williams toured with Kenny and Josh for a couple of seasons, he knew them both really well...

 

-Tab

__________________

Tab Tabscott www.squarenecked.com

beardbizguy's picture

Josh played a Beard "Josh Graves" model before being wooed back by Gibson to endorse their guitars.

 

fwiw

__________________

Howard Parker

Beardguitars LLC 301-733-8271

howard@beardguitars.com/www.beardguitars.com

Dean Upson's picture

Preston Thompson:

   To add just a bit of thought to this, I once had a conversation with Gregg McKenna in regards to the soundwell and if he built the open body, post style guitars. Well I just about got blessed out for even mentioning the post style. He built the soundwell style and that it. So along that line of thinking, if Gregg was that steadfast in his way of thinking, I can't help but think the the pickers of yesteryear would have about the same mind set. But then I still think Jerry's RQ Jones sounded better than the present Beard.

 

  pt

Is Gregg making open-bodied guitars now?  I remembered this thread http://www.reso-nation.org/forums/guitars/resophonic-weissenborn-other/2009/08/21/mckenna-open-body from a while back.

Dean

MarkinSonoma's picture

As soon as I saw this thread I thought of that Beard Josh Graves model. Howard or anyone else, do you know if that Beard had a soundwell, along the lines of a Beard Vintage R?

Josh played an R.Q. Jones on his 1977 album entitled "Same Old Blues" which I have had on vinyl since it first came out. The guitar credit on the back reads: "Josh Graves' guitar was manufactured by the R.Q. Jones Resophonic Guitar Company, Wanette, Oklahoma"

It's one of my favorite Josh albums. I bought it back then after it was first released, and I had recently acquired my circa 1930 Dobro. I remember thinking that was the only kind you could get, because in those well-before-the-internet days, I didn't know Rudy Q. Jones from Adam. The guitar has the name "Doug" inlaid on the 12th fret. And I wasn't aware if the young Jerry Douglas was playing a Jones yet.

Here is a link to a dinky photo of the cover:

http://www.lpdiscography.com/g/Graves/graves_sameold.jpg

I think it's pretty unusual for a long-time pro musician in the guitar family of instruments to only play one brand of guitar, or more specifically one guitar, through the majority of their career, like Oswald with the Dobro named 'Herman, ' or Rob and Sally with Scheerhorns, or for a number of years Ferrell Stowe with Harlows. Though they might have their favorites, like Josh had with 'Julie,' many of the great ones have played a number of brands.

Late in his career and getting toward retirement I'm speculating that Josh jumped at the chance to have a Gibson/Dobro model for financial reasons. All indications point out that he and Mrs. Graves weren't exactly thriving in retirement, I'm thinking with his health issues the medical bills alone had to be a tremendous burden.

I wish I could have supplied the beer (or wine) for Tab's session with Josh. That must have been something else!

beardbizguy's picture
As soon as I saw this thread I thought of that Beard Josh Graves model. Howard or anyone else, do you know if that Beard had a soundwell, along the lines of a Beard Vintage R?

More of a Mahogany R w/open sound well. A bigger guitar then Julie for sure.

I know Paul and Josh talked well after he signed with Gibson. I think your thoughts sound reasonable.

 

User login